10 Prompts for Customer Success Renewal Scripts

** Why Renewal Scripts Matter in Customer Success**

Here’s a hard truth: most customers don’t wake up excited to renew their contract. They’re busy, distracted, and—let’s be honest—often forget the expiration date is even coming up. That’s why the 90-day window before renewal isn’t just important—it’s your last, best chance to remind them why they signed up in the first place.

Think about it. If you wait until the contract is about to expire, you’re already playing defense. The customer has likely started comparing alternatives, questioning the value, or worse—ignoring your emails entirely. But 90 days out? That’s when you can still shape the conversation. You have time to:

• Reconnect with a personalized message
• Reinforce the ROI they’ve already seen
• Address concerns before they become deal-breakers

The Cost of Getting It Wrong

Weak renewal conversations don’t just risk losing a customer—they leave money on the table. Studies show that companies with proactive renewal strategies see 20-30% higher retention rates than those who treat renewals as an afterthought. And the numbers get worse when you factor in upsell opportunities. A poorly handled renewal call might save the contract, but it won’t uncover expansion potential.

Take the case of a SaaS company that lost 15% of its mid-market customers in a single quarter. The problem? Their renewal scripts were generic, transactional, and focused only on price. Customers felt like they were being processed, not valued. Meanwhile, a competitor with a structured, value-driven renewal approach grew their retention rate by 12% in the same period. The difference wasn’t the product—it was the conversation.

What Makes a Renewal Script Actually Work?

A great renewal script isn’t about reading from a script at all. It’s about guiding a conversation that feels natural, relevant, and—above all—focused on the customer’s success. The best scripts do three things:

1. Personalize the approach – Reference specific wins the customer has achieved with your product.
2. Reinforce value – Remind them of the problems you’ve solved, not just the features they’ve used.
3. Handle objections before they arise – Anticipate concerns like budget, competition, or changing needs.

But here’s the secret: the most effective renewal scripts don’t just rely on data—they use emotional intelligence. They acknowledge the customer’s journey, celebrate their progress, and make them feel like a partner, not a line item. Because at the end of the day, people renew with companies they trust, not just the ones with the best features.

So ask yourself: Are your renewal conversations building that trust—or just checking a box? The answer could be the difference between a customer who stays and one who walks away.

The Psychology Behind Renewal Conversations

Renewal time is not just about contracts and numbers. It’s about people making decisions. And people don’t always decide with logic. They decide with feelings first, then find reasons to justify it. This is why some customers renew without thinking, while others hesitate—even when the product works well.

Think about the last time you renewed a subscription. Did you compare every feature and price? Or did you just click “renew” because it felt easier than changing? Most customers do the same. They stick with what they know, even if a better option exists. This is called status quo bias—the brain’s way of avoiding extra work. Your job in renewal conversations is to make staying feel like the obvious, safe choice.

Why Customers Renew (or Don’t)

Customers renew for two reasons: they feel good about the product, or they fear losing something. The first is about value—they see real results. The second is about loss aversion. Studies show people hate losing $100 more than they love gaining $100. So when you talk about renewal, don’t just say, “Here’s what you get.” Say, “Here’s what you’ll lose if you don’t renew.”

For example, imagine a customer using your project management tool. They might not notice how much time they save every week. But if you say, “Without this tool, your team will waste 10 hours a month on manual updates,” suddenly, the risk feels real. That’s loss aversion in action.

The Emotional vs. Rational Battle

Customers want to believe they make smart, logical choices. But emotions drive decisions. A study by Harvard Business Review found that emotionally connected customers are 52% more valuable than just “satisfied” ones. So if your renewal script only talks about features and ROI, you’re missing the bigger picture.

Ask yourself: Does your customer feel heard? Do they trust your team? Do they see your product as part of their success story? If not, even the best data won’t save the deal. One SaaS company increased renewals by 20% just by adding a simple line to their script: “We’ve loved being part of your growth this year. Let’s keep building together.” Small change, big impact.

Common Objections and How to Handle Them

Every objection has a hidden fear behind it. Here are the top five—and how to address them:

1. “We need to cut costs.”

   • Fear: “I’ll look bad if I spend money without clear value.”
   • Response: “I get it—budgets are tight. Let’s look at how much time and money you’ve saved this year. Would it cost more to switch to a cheaper tool and retrain your team?”

2. “We’re not sure about ROI.”

   • Fear: “I don’t want to defend this purchase later.”
   • Response: “Let’s walk through the numbers together. Last quarter, your team completed 30% more projects with this tool. How much is that worth to your goals?”

3. “We’re looking at competitors.”

   • Fear: “What if I miss out on something better?”
   • Response: “I’d be happy to compare features. But remember, switching means downtime, training, and risk. Is that worth the unknown?”

4. “Our team isn’t using it enough.”

   • Fear: “I made a bad decision.”
   • Response: “Let’s fix that. What’s one feature your team loves? We can set up a quick training to get everyone on board.”

5. “We’re restructuring internally.”

   • Fear: “This might not fit our new direction.”
   • Response: “That makes sense. How can we adjust your plan to match your new goals? Maybe a smaller package or different features?”

Framing Renewal as the Safe Choice

The best renewal scripts don’t sell—they reassure. They make the customer feel smart for staying. Here’s how:

• Use social proof: “90% of our customers in your industry renew because they see X results.”
• Highlight stability: “No surprises, no hidden fees—just the same great service you’ve relied on.”
• Make it easy: “I’ll handle everything. Just say ‘yes,’ and we’ll take care of the rest.”

One customer success team tested this approach. They sent two renewal emails:

• Email A: “Your contract expires in 30 days. Click here to renew.”
• Email B: “We’ve helped you save 50 hours this year. Let’s keep that momentum going. Here’s your easy renewal link.”

Email B had a 40% higher response rate. Why? It reminded the customer of the value—and made renewing feel like the natural next step.

Balancing Data and Emotion

Data proves your product works. Emotion makes the customer care. The best scripts do both. For example:

“Your team’s productivity increased by 25% this year with our tool. That’s like adding an extra day to every week. Let’s keep that going—your competitors aren’t slowing down.”

This line gives a number (25%) but also paints a picture (extra day every week). It’s not just about what the product does—it’s about what the customer gains.

The Bottom Line

Renewal conversations are about trust. If the customer trusts you, they’ll renew. If they don’t, no discount or feature list will save the deal. So focus on making them feel good about their choice. Remind them of the wins. Address their fears. And always, always make staying the easiest option.

Because at the end of the day, people don’t renew products—they renew relationships.

10 High-Impact Renewal Script Prompts (With Examples)

Renewal conversations can feel like walking a tightrope. You need to remind customers why they signed up in the first place—but also show them why they should stay. The best renewal scripts don’t just ask for another year. They make customers want to say yes.

The problem? Most renewal scripts sound the same. “We’d love to continue working with you.” “Here’s your renewal quote.” “Let us know if you have questions.” These messages don’t build excitement. They don’t address doubts. And they don’t make customers feel valued.

So how do you make renewal conversations actually work? You need scripts that are flexible, personal, and focused on their success—not just your contract. Below are 10 high-impact prompts to help you craft renewal messages that get results.

---

1. The Value Recap Script

Customers forget. It’s not personal—it’s just how our brains work. That’s why the first step in any renewal conversation should be a quick recap of the value they’ve already gotten.

How to do it in 30 seconds or less:

• Pick 1-2 big wins from the past year (e.g., “You saved 20 hours a month on reporting”).
• Tie it to a number or clear outcome (e.g., “That’s like gaining an extra workday every month”).
• Keep it simple. No jargon.

Example script: “Last year, we helped you [achieve X result]—like when you [specific example]. That saved your team [time/money/resources], which let you focus on [their bigger goal]. Here’s how we can build on that success this year…”

When to use this: Early in the renewal conversation. Before you talk about pricing, contracts, or next steps, remind them why they signed up in the first place.

---

2. The Future-Focused Script

Past success is great—but customers care more about what’s next. This script shifts the conversation from “what we’ve done” to “what we can do together.”

How to make it work:

• Start with their goals. Ask: “What’s your biggest priority for [next quarter/year]?”
• Show how your product fits into that plan.
• Be specific. Instead of “We can help with growth,” say “We can help you launch in [new market] by [specific feature].”

Example script: “Based on your goals for [Q3], here’s how we can help: [Feature 1] will let you [achieve X], and [Feature 2] will solve [Problem Y]. That way, you’re not just renewing—you’re setting up for your next big win.”

Pro tip: If they’re not sure about their goals, ask: “What’s one thing that would make this year a success for you?” Then tie your renewal to that.

---

3. The Competitive Differentiation Script

What if your customer is looking at other options? This script helps you stand out—without badmouthing competitors.

How to position your solution:

• Focus on their experience. Instead of saying “Competitor X is bad,” say “Here’s how we’ve helped you in ways others can’t.”
• Use data. “While [Competitor] offers [Feature], our [Feature] helped you [specific result].”
• Keep it positive. The goal isn’t to attack—it’s to remind them why they chose you.

Example script: “I know you’re exploring options, so I wanted to share how we’re different. While [Competitor] offers [X], our [Y] has helped you [Z result]. For example, [specific customer story].”

When to use this: Only if they mention looking at other options. If they don’t bring it up, don’t introduce the idea.

---

4. The Budget-Friendly Renewal Script

Cost is the #1 reason customers don’t renew. But you don’t have to discount to keep them. This script helps you address budget concerns without lowering your price.

How to justify pricing:

• Offer flexible payment plans (e.g., quarterly instead of annual).
• Break down the cost of churn. “If you switch, you’ll lose [X] and spend [Y] on training. Here’s how we can make renewal easier.”
• Show ROI. “For every $1 you spend, you get [X] in value.”

Example script: “I understand budget is a priority. Let’s explore how we can structure this to fit your needs. For example, we could [option 1] or [option 2]. That way, you keep the value without stretching your budget.”

Data-backed tip: Studies show it costs 5x more to acquire a new customer than to retain an existing one. Use this to frame renewal as the smarter choice.

---

5. The Upsell Opportunity Script

Renewal conversations are a great time to explore expansion—but you have to do it the right way. This script helps you identify upsell opportunities without being pushy.

How to gauge interest:

• Start with a question. “What’s one challenge you’re still facing that we could help with?”
• Use social proof. “Many customers in your industry add [Feature] to solve [Problem]. Would that be helpful for you?”
• Make it easy to say no. “If that’s not a priority, no problem—we can focus on [current plan].”

Example script: “I noticed you’re not using [Feature]. Many of our customers in [their industry] add it to [solve X problem]. Would you like me to show you how it works?”

When to use this: Only if they’re engaged and happy. If they’re hesitant about renewing, focus on retention first.

---

6. The Risk Mitigation Script

Some customers don’t renew because they don’t see the downside of leaving. This script frames renewal as the safe choice.

How to highlight risks:

• Focus on disruption. “If you switch, you’ll lose [X] and spend [Y] on training.”
• Show the cost of churn. “Last year, customers who left spent [X] months getting back to where they were.”
• Keep it factual. Don’t scare them—just show the reality.

Example script: “I want to make sure you’re set up for success. If you don’t renew, here’s what you risk losing: [X], [Y], and [Z]. Let’s talk about how we can avoid that.”

When to use this: For customers who are disengaged or considering leaving. Use sparingly—this isn’t a fear tactic, just a reality check.

---

7. The Social Proof Script

People trust other people more than they trust sales pitches. This script uses case studies, testimonials, and peer comparisons to build confidence.

How to personalize social proof:

• Use customers like them. “Companies like [Similar Customer] saw [X] results after renewing.”
• Share a quick story. “One of our customers in [their industry] renewed and then [achieved X].”
• Make it relatable. “I know you care about [their goal], so I wanted to share how [Customer] used us to [result].”

Example script: “I know you’re focused on [their goal], so I wanted to share how [Similar Customer] used us to [achieve X]. They renewed last year and just hit [Y milestone].”

Pro tip: If you don’t have a case study, use a testimonial. “Here’s what [Customer] said about renewing: [quote].“

---

8. The Customized Renewal Script

Generic renewal messages don’t work. This script helps you tailor the conversation to their unique needs.

How to personalize:

• Use data. “I see you’re using [Feature] a lot—here’s how we can expand that.”
• Reference their goals. “You mentioned [goal] last quarter—here’s how we can help with that.”
• Adjust the plan. “Given your focus on [X], here’s how we can tweak your renewal to match.”

Example script: “Given your focus on [Specific Goal], here’s how we can adjust your plan: [Option 1] or [Option 2]. That way, you’re not paying for what you don’t need.”

Tools to help:

• CRM data (past conversations, usage)
• Product analytics (which features they use most)
• Support tickets (what problems they’ve had)

---

9. The Objection Handling Script

Customers will have objections. This script helps you respond before they even bring them up.

Common objections and how to handle them:

• “We’re not using all the features.” “I understand—let’s discuss how we can optimize your usage or adjust your plan.”
• “It’s too expensive.” “Let’s break down the ROI. For every $1 you spend, you get [X] in value.”
• “We’re exploring other options.” “I’d love to understand what you’re looking for. Here’s how we compare to [Competitor].”

The “Feel, Felt, Found” technique:

1. “I understand how you feel.” (Empathy)
2. “Other customers have felt the same way.” (Social proof)
3. “Here’s what they found after renewing.” (Solution)

Example script: “I get why you’d feel that way. Other customers have felt the same, but here’s what they found after renewing: [X result].“

---

10. The Closing Script

The best renewal conversations end with clear next steps. This script helps you close the deal without being pushy.

How to end the conversation:

• Summarize the value. “Here’s what you’ll get if you renew: [X], [Y], [Z].”
• Set a deadline. “To lock in this rate, we’ll need your approval by [date].”
• Make it easy. “I’ll send over the contract—just reply with a ‘yes’ if you’re ready.”

Example script: “To lock in your renewal at this rate, here’s what we need from you by [Date]: [Action 1] and [Action 2]. I’ll send over the contract today—just let me know if you have any questions.”

For unresponsive customers:

• Follow up with a short message. “Just circling back—did you get a chance to review the renewal details?”
• Offer help. “If you’re stuck on anything, I’m happy to jump on a quick call.”

---

Which Script Will You Try First?

Renewal conversations don’t have to be awkward. With the right scripts, you can turn them into opportunities to deepen relationships, uncover new needs, and keep customers for the long haul.

Start with one or two prompts that fit your customers best. Test them, tweak them, and see what works. The goal isn’t perfection—it’s progress. And every “yes” is a step in the right direction.

How to Customize Renewal Scripts for Different Customer Segments

Renewal conversations are not one-size-fits-all. A small business owner with 10 employees has different needs than a Fortune 500 company with thousands. A healthcare provider worries about compliance, while a SaaS startup cares about growth metrics. If your renewal script sounds the same for everyone, you’re missing a big opportunity to connect—and keep—your customers.

The good news? Small tweaks can make a big difference. Let’s break down how to tailor your approach for different segments, so every customer feels like you get them.

---

Enterprise vs. SMB: Why Size Changes Everything

Enterprise customers move slow. They have multiple decision-makers, complex contracts, and strict procurement processes. A renewal conversation with them might take months and involve legal teams. On the other hand, SMBs (small and medium businesses) often decide fast—sometimes in a single call. They care about simplicity, cost, and quick wins.

Key differences to remember:

• Decision-makers: Enterprise = multiple stakeholders (CFO, IT, department heads). SMB = usually the owner or a single manager.
• Contract complexity: Enterprise deals often have custom terms, SLAs, and add-ons. SMBs prefer standard packages.
• Time to renew: Enterprise renewals can take 3-6 months. SMBs might sign in 30 days.

Example scripts:

For Enterprise: “We’ve seen great results from your team’s use of [feature X], especially in [specific department]. As we prepare for renewal, I’d love to connect with your procurement team to ensure the contract aligns with your 2025 goals. Would it help if I shared a case study from a similar enterprise client?”

For SMB: “I know you’re busy, so I’ll keep this short. Your team has been using [product] for [X months], and I wanted to check in—what’s working well? If there’s anything we can improve, let’s fix it now so renewal is a no-brainer. How does a quick 15-minute call next week sound?”

---

Industry-Specific Scripts: Speak Their Language

A healthcare provider doesn’t care about the same things as a fintech startup. Tailoring your script to their industry shows you understand their world—and their pain points.

Here’s how to adapt for common verticals:

• Healthcare: Focus on compliance, patient outcomes, and security. “With HIPAA updates coming in Q3, we’ve added [feature] to help your team stay compliant. Would it make sense to review how this aligns with your current workflows?”

• Finance: Highlight security, audit trails, and ROI. “Given the recent SEC guidelines, our [feature] now includes enhanced audit logs. I’d love to walk you through how this reduces risk for your team.”

• SaaS/Tech: Talk about scalability, integrations, and growth. “Your user base grew 40% this year—congrats! To support that growth, we’ve added [feature]. Let’s discuss how to optimize your plan for the next phase.”

• Retail/E-commerce: Emphasize sales impact, customer experience, and ease of use. “Your team used [feature] to increase checkout conversions by 12% last quarter. With the holidays coming up, would it help to explore how we can replicate that success?”

Pro tip: If you’re not sure what matters to a customer’s industry, ask! “What’s the biggest challenge your team is facing right now?” Their answer will tell you exactly what to focus on.

---

High-Touch vs. Low-Touch Customers: The Right Level of Attention

Not every customer needs (or wants) a white-glove experience. Some have dedicated Customer Success Managers (CSMs) and expect regular check-ins. Others prefer self-service and only reach out when they have a problem. Your renewal script should match their preferred style.

For high-touch customers (with a CSM):

• Schedule a live call or meeting.
• Review their usage data, goals, and any roadblocks.
• Offer personalized recommendations.

Example script: “Over the past year, your team has used [product] to achieve [specific result]. As we look ahead, I’d love to discuss how we can support [new goal]. Would you prefer a quick call or a detailed proposal?”

For low-touch customers (self-service):

• Use automated emails or chatbots for efficiency.
• Keep it short, friendly, and action-oriented.
• Include clear next steps (e.g., “Click here to renew”).

Example email: Subject: Your [Product] renewal is coming up! “Hi [Name], Your [Product] subscription renews on [date]. We’ve loved having you as a customer and want to make renewal easy. Here’s what’s new this year:

• [Feature 1]
• [Feature 2] Click below to renew in just 2 minutes. Questions? Reply to this email—we’re happy to help! [Renew Now Button]”

Warning: Don’t assume low-touch customers don’t want a conversation. If they’re at risk (low usage, support tickets), reach out personally. “I noticed your team hasn’t logged in recently. Is everything okay? I’d love to help.”

---

At-Risk vs. Loyal Customers: Different Scripts for Different Needs

Not all customers are created equal. Some are happy and engaged. Others are quietly slipping away. Your renewal script should reflect their current state.

How to spot at-risk customers:

• Low product usage (e.g., logins, feature adoption).
• Increased support tickets or complaints.
• No response to previous outreach.
• Competitor mentions in conversations.

Script for at-risk customers: “I noticed your team hasn’t been using [product] as much lately. Is there something we can improve? I’d love to set up a quick call to understand what’s not working and how we can fix it. No pressure—just want to help.”

Script for loyal customers: “Your team has been a great partner, and we’ve loved seeing you achieve [specific result]. As a thank-you, we’d like to offer [discount/upgrade/early access to a new feature]. Would that be valuable for you?”

Key takeaway: At-risk customers need empathy and solutions. Loyal customers need appreciation and incentives. Don’t mix them up!

---

Final Tip: Test, Learn, and Improve

The best renewal scripts aren’t set in stone. Try different approaches, track what works, and refine over time. For example:

• A/B test email subject lines (e.g., “Your renewal is coming up” vs. “Let’s talk about your goals”).
• Track response rates for calls vs. emails.
• Ask customers for feedback: “Was this conversation helpful? What could we do better?”

Remember: Renewals aren’t just about contracts. They’re about relationships. The more you tailor your script to the customer, the more they’ll feel valued—and the more likely they’ll stay.

Tools and Templates to Streamline Renewal Scripting

Renewal conversations don’t have to feel like a last-minute scramble. With the right tools and templates, you can turn them into smooth, predictable processes that actually strengthen customer relationships. The key? Automation that feels personal, data that tells you what to say, and scripts that don’t sound like scripts at all.

Let’s be honest—no one enjoys the awkward “Hey, your contract’s ending soon” email. But when you pair the right tools with smart scripting, those conversations become opportunities to show value, address concerns, and even upsell. Here’s how to make it happen without reinventing the wheel every time.

---

CRM and Automation: Your Renewal Scripting Sidekick

Most teams already use a CRM, but few use it to its full potential for renewals. Tools like HubSpot, Salesforce, or Gainsight can trigger renewal conversations automatically—so you’re never caught off guard when a contract expires. Here’s how to set it up:

• Automated reminders: Schedule emails or tasks 90, 60, and 30 days before renewal. Example: “Hi [Name], your contract renews in 90 days. Let’s chat about how we can make the next year even better.”
• Personalized follow-ups: Use merge tags to pull in customer data (e.g., “We noticed your team loved [Feature X]—want to explore [Feature Y] next?”).
• Task assignments: Assign renewal conversations to the right person (account manager, CSM, or sales rep) with clear deadlines.

Pro tip: In HubSpot, use the “Sequences” feature to send a series of emails with different renewal prompts. In Salesforce, set up a “Renewal Path” to track progress. Gainsight users can leverage “Playbooks” to standardize the process.

The goal isn’t to replace human conversation—it’s to start the conversation at the right time, with the right context.

---

Script Templates: The Framework for Every Renewal

Even the best tools need great scripts. But writing a new one from scratch for every customer? That’s a time-suck. Instead, use templates and frameworks to speed up the process while keeping things personal.

The AIDA Framework for Renewals

AIDA (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action) works for renewals just like it does for sales. Here’s how to apply it:

1. Attention: Grab their focus with a quick win. “Your team hit [X] milestones this year—let’s build on that.”
2. Interest: Highlight what’s new or improved. “We’ve added [Feature] since you signed up—here’s how it can help.”
3. Desire: Show the cost of not renewing. “Without [Product], you’d need to spend [X] hours/month on [Task].”
4. Action: Make the next step clear. “Can we schedule 15 minutes to discuss your goals for next year?”

Downloadable templates: We’ve created 10 ready-to-use scripts (one for each prompt in this article). Plug in your customer’s name, a few details, and you’re good to go. [Insert link to templates here.]

---

Data-Driven Scripts: What Your Customers Aren’t Telling You

The best renewal scripts don’t guess—they know. Product usage data, NPS scores, and support tickets tell you exactly what your customer thinks (even if they won’t say it out loud).

• Product usage data (Pendo, Mixpanel, Totango): Are they logging in daily? Ignoring key features? “We noticed you’re not using [Feature]—here’s how it can save you 10 hours/week.”
• NPS scores: A low score? Address it head-on. “We saw your feedback about [Issue]—here’s how we’ve fixed it.”
• Support tickets: Frequent complaints? Propose a solution. “You’ve reached out about [Problem] a few times—let’s talk about how to make it smoother.”

Example: A customer with low login rates might get this script: “We’ve noticed your team hasn’t been as active in the platform lately. Is there something we can do to help you get more value?” No guesswork, just actionable insights.

---

A/B Testing: The Secret to Higher Renewal Rates

Not all scripts work for all customers. That’s why A/B testing is your best friend. Try two versions of the same email or call script and see which one performs better.

What to test:

• Subject lines: “Your renewal is coming up” vs. “How can we make next year even better?”
• Call-to-action: “Let’s schedule a call” vs. “Reply with your top priority for next year.”
• Tone: Formal vs. casual. “Per our records, your contract expires…” vs. “Hey [Name], let’s chat about what’s next!”

Metrics to track:

• Response rate: Are they replying?
• Renewal rate: Are they signing?
• Upsell success: Are they adding more seats or features?

Case study: One SaaS company tested two renewal scripts. Version A (direct) had a 30% response rate. Version B (customer-focused) had a 55% response rate—and a 20% higher renewal rate. Small tweaks, big results.

---

Putting It All Together

Renewal scripting doesn’t have to be complicated. Start with your CRM to automate the timing, use templates to save time, pull in data to personalize, and test to optimize. The result? Conversations that feel natural, customers who feel heard, and renewals that happen almost on autopilot.

Next step: Pick one tool or template from this section and try it with your next renewal. Which one will you start with?

Case Studies: How Top Companies Use Renewal Scripts to Reduce Churn

Renewal conversations can feel like walking a tightrope. One wrong word, and the customer hesitates. But get it right? They sign without a second thought. The difference often comes down to preparation—and the best companies know this. They don’t leave renewals to chance. Instead, they use scripts as a starting point, then adapt based on real customer feedback.

Here’s the thing: scripts aren’t about sounding robotic. They’re about having a clear plan. A way to guide the conversation so you cover what matters most—value, pain points, and next steps. The companies below didn’t just write scripts and forget them. They tested, refined, and trained their teams to use them effectively. And the results speak for themselves.

How a SaaS Company Cut Churn by 30% with a 90-Day Playbook

A mid-sized SaaS company was losing customers at renewal time—even happy ones. The problem? Their customer success team was winging it. Some CSMs asked about renewals too late. Others didn’t ask at all until the contract was almost up. The result? A 15% churn rate that was eating into revenue.

Their solution was simple: a 90-day renewal playbook. Starting three months before the contract ended, CSMs followed a structured approach:

• Day 90: Sent a “health check” email with a quick survey. “How’s the product working for you? What could be better?”
• Day 60: Scheduled a 15-minute check-in call. Focused on two things: 1) What the customer loved, and 2) What they wished they could do (but couldn’t yet).
• Day 30: Sent a personalized renewal proposal. Highlighted how the product solved their biggest pain points—and what they’d miss if they left.

The key? They didn’t wait for the customer to bring up renewal. By starting early, they had time to address concerns before they became deal-breakers. And the scripts? They weren’t set in stone. CSMs were trained to listen for cues and adjust. For example, if a customer mentioned budget concerns, the script shifted to focus on ROI.

The result? Churn dropped by 30% in six months. Even better? Upsell opportunities increased because CSMs uncovered unmet needs during those early conversations.

Enterprise Software Provider: How Upsell Scripts Turned Renewals into Revenue

For enterprise software companies, renewals are a chance to grow—not just retain. But many CSMs avoid upselling during renewals because they don’t want to seem pushy. One enterprise provider decided to change that.

They trained their CSMs to use value-based upsell scripts during renewal conversations. The goal wasn’t to sell more features—it was to solve bigger problems. Here’s how they did it:

1. Started with the customer’s goals. “Last time we spoke, you mentioned wanting to reduce manual work. How’s that going?”
2. Connected the dots. “We’ve helped other teams like yours cut that time in half with [Feature X]. Would that be valuable for you?”
3. Made it easy to say yes. “We can add that to your renewal at a 10% discount if we sign by [date].”

The biggest lesson? Not every upsell attempt worked—and that was okay. Some customers said no, but others said yes because the offer was relevant. The company saw a 25% increase in upsells during renewals.

But they also learned from their mistakes. Early on, some CSMs pushed features that didn’t align with the customer’s needs. The fix? They added a pre-renewal discovery call to uncover pain points before making any offers.

E-Commerce Platform: Personalization at Scale

For an e-commerce platform with thousands of customers, personalization seemed impossible. How could they tailor renewal messages when they had so many users? The answer: data + automation.

They started by segmenting customers based on usage:

• Power users (high engagement, frequent logins)
• At-risk users (low engagement, infrequent logins)
• Mid-tier users (steady but not growing)

For each group, they created customized renewal scripts with different focuses:

• Power users: “You’re one of our top users! Here’s how we can help you do even more next year.”
• At-risk users: “We noticed you haven’t logged in as much lately. Is there something we can improve?”
• Mid-tier users: “Here’s how other customers like you are getting more value from [Feature Y].”

They used email templates to scale the process but added personal touches, like:

• The customer’s name
• Their most-used feature
• A specific pain point they’d mentioned before

The result? Renewal rates improved by 18%, and customers felt heard—not just like another number.

The Common Thread: Scripts Are a Starting Point, Not a Crutch

These companies didn’t succeed because their scripts were perfect. They succeeded because they used scripts as a framework, not a script. They listened, adapted, and focused on what the customer needed—not just what they wanted to sell.

So, what can you take from these examples?

• Start early. Don’t wait until the last minute.
• Listen more than you talk. Scripts help, but the best renewals are conversations.
• Personalize where it counts. Even small details make a difference.

The best renewal scripts don’t sound like scripts at all. They sound like a natural conversation—one where the customer feels valued, understood, and excited to continue the relationship.

Common Mistakes to Avoid in Renewal Scripts

Renewal conversations are tricky. You want to keep the customer happy, but you also need to make sure they stay. Many people make big mistakes here—mistakes that can cost you the renewal. Let’s talk about what not to do.

Don’t Sound Like a Used Car Salesman

You know that feeling when someone is pushing too hard? Like they only care about the sale, not you? That’s how customers feel when renewal scripts sound too salesy. Phrases like “This is a limited-time offer!” or “You don’t want to miss out!” make customers roll their eyes.

Instead, focus on their needs. Ask questions like:

• “How has the product worked for you so far?”
• “What would make your experience even better?”
• “Are there any challenges we can help with?”

This shows you care about their success, not just the contract.

One-Size-Fits-All Scripts Don’t Work

Every customer is different. Some are happy, some are frustrated, and some don’t even remember they have a contract. If you use the same script for everyone, you’ll miss the mark.

For example:

• A happy customer? Celebrate their wins. “I saw your team hit [goal]—that’s amazing!”
• A frustrated customer? Listen first. “I hear this has been tough. How can we fix it?”
• A distracted customer? Remind them why they signed up. “Last time, you said [reason]. Is that still important?”

The more you personalize, the better the conversation.

Ignoring the Customer’s Emotional State

People don’t make decisions based on logic alone. If a customer is stressed, annoyed, or indifferent, your script won’t work—no matter how good it is.

Watch for signs of disengagement:

• Short, one-word answers (“Fine.” “Okay.”)
• Delayed responses (“I’ll get back to you.”)
• Avoiding the conversation (“I’m busy right now.”)

If you notice these, slow down. Ask open-ended questions:

• “What’s been the biggest surprise since you started using [product]?”
• “If you could change one thing, what would it be?”

This helps you understand their real feelings.

Overpromising (or Underpromising) in Renewals

Some people make big promises to keep a customer. “We’ll double your results in 30 days!” But if you can’t deliver, they’ll leave—and tell others about the bad experience.

Others play it too safe. “We’ll try our best.” That doesn’t inspire confidence.

The best approach? Be honest but optimistic.

• “We’ve helped similar teams improve [metric] by X%. Let’s see if we can do the same for you.”
• “Here’s what we can commit to—and here’s what we’ll aim for.”

This sets realistic expectations without overselling.

Forgetting to Follow Up

A single email or call isn’t enough. Customers get busy, forget, or put things off. If you don’t follow up, they might not renew—not because they don’t want to, but because they didn’t have time to think about it.

A good renewal strategy includes:

1. First touch (90 days out): “Just checking in—how’s everything going?”
2. Second touch (60 days out): “We’d love to keep working with you. Any questions?”
3. Final touch (30 days out): “Your contract ends soon. Let’s talk about next steps.”

Each message should be short, friendly, and easy to respond to.

The Bottom Line

Renewals aren’t just about contracts—they’re about relationships. Avoid these mistakes, and your customers will feel heard, valued, and more likely to stay. The best scripts don’t sound like scripts at all. They sound like a real conversation.

Conclusion: Building a Renewal Script Strategy That Works

Renewal conversations don’t have to feel like a sales pitch. The best scripts sound like real talk—where you listen more than you speak, and the customer feels heard. From the 10 prompts we covered, a few stand out as game-changers. The “value recap” script works best for happy customers who just need a nudge. The “pain point” script is perfect when they’re on the fence. And the “future vision” script? That’s your secret weapon for upsells.

But here’s the thing: no single script works for every customer. The magic happens when you mix and match. Start with an open-ended question to understand their goals. Then, use their own words to show how your product fits into their future. And always end with a clear next step—whether it’s a follow-up call or a contract review.

Your 30-Day Action Plan

Ready to put this into practice? Here’s how to start:

1. Pick 2-3 scripts from the list and test them with your next renewals.
2. Train your team—run a 30-minute workshop to practice role-playing.
3. Track what works—note which scripts get the best responses.
4. Refine and repeat—tweak based on feedback and results.

Success isn’t just about renewal rates. It’s about customer satisfaction. Are they excited to continue? Do they see the value? If yes, you’re doing it right.

The Future of Renewal Conversations

AI and automation will change how we handle renewals—but not why we do them. In the next five years, expect more personalized scripts powered by data. Imagine a tool that suggests the perfect prompt based on a customer’s usage history. Or chatbots that handle the first touchpoint, freeing up your team for deeper conversations.

But no matter how tech advances, the core remains the same: renewals are about relationships. The best scripts don’t sound like scripts at all. They sound like a friend checking in, asking, “How can we make this even better for you?”

So start small. Try one script this week. See what happens. The worst that can happen? You learn. The best? You keep a customer—and maybe even grow the account. What’s your next move?